2008 – Heritage Federal Credit Union
2009 – First Federal Savings Bank
2010 – Old National Bank
2011 – VanDyk Mortgage
2012 – Evansville Courier & Press
2013 – McMahon Exterminating
2014 – Southwestern Indiana Land Title
2015 – Evansville Teachers Federal Credit Union
2016 – Jagoe Homes
2017 – First Federal Savings Bank
2018 – Mortgage Masters
2019 – Columbia Title
2020 – Foreman Watson Land Title
2021 – Champion Home Inspections